Holloway (1985) covered this subfamily in
part but, because of problems in developing a clear definition of it, and thus
establishing its extent, several potential genera were omitted. Kobes (1985)
covered a similar set of genera in the slightly more diverse Sumatran fauna.
However, he later (Kobes, 1992) brought in three further genera from the
traditional Ophiderinae, namely Baorisa Moore, Trisula Moore and Donda Moore, though he left Belciana Walker in the Ophiderinae.
Holloway (2005)
and Kononenko & Pinratana (2005) supported the transference of these genera
to the ‘trifine’ clade and added Belciana, Sundwarda Swinhoe and Ortopla Walker to this list, though Kononenko & Pinratana
placed Belciana and Donda in their Acronictinae, together with Antitrisuloides Holloway, described in the Pantheinae by Holloway
(1985).
Holloway (2005)
also identified the genus Cyclodes Guenée and the Arcte Kollar group of genera as further potential
pantheines, though he defined the Pantheinae in a very broad sense as
‘quadrifine’ members of the ‘trifine’ clade with features such as: reduced
phragma lobes between the first and second abdominal tergites; a scaled lower
clypeofrons; dark and pale rings to the tarsal segments of the legs; a sinuous
pale fascia within the darker border of the hindwing, with the strongest
flexure at the tornus; larvae with all abdominal prolegs developed. The larvae
in most genera appear hairy, but this effect is produced by prominence of the
primary setae only in Cyclodes, the Arcte group and Donda.
However, secondary setae on verrucae are present in Belciana, Trisula
and Trisuloides Moore, the last a pantheine genus first recorded for
Borneo by Martini & Thöny (1993).
There is still no useful definition
of the Pantheinae, though Hacker & Zilli (2007) reviewed characters in a
number of groups, including the Pantheinae, when proposing their new subfamily
Thiacidinae (possibly with the inclusion of Trisula; see p. 10). Again,
no clear apomorphies became apparent. Therefore, the concept of Pantheinae
applied here is that of a useful, but potentially paraphyletic assemblage of
genera that appear to be relatively basal within the trifine clade, as
indicated in Lafontaine & Fibiger (2006: fig 27). It is presented in the
hope that it will provide a focus for future research.
>>Forward
<<Return to Contents page
|